This review is long overdue! What an amazing bakery and Team! Their food is delicious and attention to detail is spot-on. If you have special requests (allergies, preferences, etc) they are most accommodating. We’ve been going to this bakery for years and have not been disappointed.
This is the first year we’ve been able to order their Yule Log cake - Wow! It is great and the presentation is beautiful.
Thank you!
This review is long overdue! We used them for our small cutting cake for our June wedding and loved how it turned out! They were easy to communicate with and the take-home tasting tray made the decision process so fun. Definitely recommend!
It was my kids and I first time here and it will not be our last. I got a chocolate chip cookie, my oldest daughter tried red velvet for the fist time in the form of a cupcake, thr youngest daughter had a vanilla cupcake, and my son, who is more of a salty person over sweets, got a triple chocolate brownie and he loved it. The prices are great and you get more than enough for what you paid for. The parking is in a very small shopping center so I recommend parking on the street (free 1 hour parking).
Best birthday cake EVER! We ordered the 6" Far Out Frangelico and it was incredible. Rich, creamy and moist! On a scale from 1 to 10, I would give this cake 20 stars. (UPDATE: We also ended up ordering this cake for my husbands birthday as well, and will be ordering it again, for Christmas). 12/14/25
Once In A Blue Moon Bakery in Cary is my go-to bakery!! I plan monthly dinners with a group of eleven ladies and we celebrate each other’s birthdays. I always have Once In A Blue Moon Bakery make the birthday cakes, and I always have their cake artist(s) add decor to the top and sides of the cake. They do a PHENOMENAL job each and every time! Attached are a few pics of a cake I just had them make for one of our birthday dinners...just incredible attention to detail...and the cakes are ALWAYS super delicious! Leanna is my go-to person for ordering/designing my cakes...she, and the entire staff, at this bakery are wonderful (a special shout out to Michelle, their lead cake artist)! If you have not tried this bakery, put it on your list, you will not be disappointed!!
Mark L
a month agoThis review is long overdue! What an amazing bakery and Team! Their food is delicious and attention to detail is spot-on. If you have special requests (allergies, preferences, etc) they are most accommodating. We’ve been going to this bakery for years and have not been disappointed. This is the first year we’ve been able to order their Yule Log cake - Wow! It is great and the presentation is beautiful. Thank you!
Brittany H
a month agoThis review is long overdue! We used them for our small cutting cake for our June wedding and loved how it turned out! They were easy to communicate with and the take-home tasting tray made the decision process so fun. Definitely recommend!
Anjelica Rice
5 months agoIt was my kids and I first time here and it will not be our last. I got a chocolate chip cookie, my oldest daughter tried red velvet for the fist time in the form of a cupcake, thr youngest daughter had a vanilla cupcake, and my son, who is more of a salty person over sweets, got a triple chocolate brownie and he loved it. The prices are great and you get more than enough for what you paid for. The parking is in a very small shopping center so I recommend parking on the street (free 1 hour parking).
Beth Wilson
2 months agoBest birthday cake EVER! We ordered the 6" Far Out Frangelico and it was incredible. Rich, creamy and moist! On a scale from 1 to 10, I would give this cake 20 stars. (UPDATE: We also ended up ordering this cake for my husbands birthday as well, and will be ordering it again, for Christmas). 12/14/25
K Stu
5 months agoOnce In A Blue Moon Bakery in Cary is my go-to bakery!! I plan monthly dinners with a group of eleven ladies and we celebrate each other’s birthdays. I always have Once In A Blue Moon Bakery make the birthday cakes, and I always have their cake artist(s) add decor to the top and sides of the cake. They do a PHENOMENAL job each and every time! Attached are a few pics of a cake I just had them make for one of our birthday dinners...just incredible attention to detail...and the cakes are ALWAYS super delicious! Leanna is my go-to person for ordering/designing my cakes...she, and the entire staff, at this bakery are wonderful (a special shout out to Michelle, their lead cake artist)! If you have not tried this bakery, put it on your list, you will not be disappointed!!